Josh Brown put up a post this week discussing some ideas from Brian McLaren’s new book, Everything Must Change. I copied my responses here below because I realized that I would like to share my views on my blog. Below are my respones
I think we give God and evil too much credit.
If it stopped raining just when you wanted…that just had to be God and he did it just for you…. couldn’t it just be that it stopped raining for a second. Or when someone goes in to remission from cancer, couldn’t it just have been the chemo?
And as far as evil, I don’t think it is evil as much as it is choice. “God” may be just another word for free will, and then evil is just really a bad or really really really bad decision(s).
As humas we have the capacity to make huge choices, these can be good, these can be bad, but maybe that is all it is…and God and Evil have nothing to do with it.
Later Josh touched on a quote from Brian McClaren’s new book, Everything Must Change.
Here is a quote:
Since the human race is in such desperate trouble, Jesus seeks to answer this question: What must be done about the mess we’re in?”
I don’t think that humans are in desperate trouble. I mean I think there are some really sad things going on, and things that are happening in the world sadden me, but I also see a ton of good in people who are working to change the world for the sake of humanity and what is good.
I don’t think we have to be so pessimistic about it. There are so many great things going on that are making the world better. There are tons of people saying that doing good for other countries, for instance, the US setting up clean wells in Africa, could stop wars. These are ideas created by humans…the “good” can combat “evil”. The past two posts snippets have shown that people still live with the idea that because we are human, we are forever flawed. That we are covered with sin and are unholy and unworthy. I don’t think there could be anything worse for the human race than to think that we are broken and flawed. Pessimism can promote laziness, the idea that, well, I am not good enough to do anything right, so I just wont. This kind of depression-like state destroys people.
So, if people do think that there is such a mess, maybe we need to go back to where it started, and it might just be that is started with an a feeling of worthlessness which created anger and hate, which created a “mess.”
I went on to say that I did not think that most people are doing good because of a higher framework or being.
I am just going to use myself as an example. Before I ever knew what Jesus did, when I was very little (this is NOT to toot my horn, but I can’t really speak for other people) I used to get so upset at night about babies being hungry and I wrote President Bush a letter saying that dolphins are being caught in nets and dying (I got a little picture with this signature on it and my dad thought that was cool). Now I have incredible parents, but they never said or even thought, well Jesus or God cares about babies and dolphins so you should too. And I didn’t feel or care about these things at all because of Jesus, I just think that people are born pretty good people. I think crazy families can present challenges for people growing up. I think there have been some amazing people that do amazing things and it has nothing at all to do with Jesus but everything to do with the goodness of humanity.
And yes I agree that some great people are centered on a non-violent, servant example, and the story, and what I want to emphasize the word story, of Jesus showed that, and that is good, but I don’t think it has to be because of Jesus. I think before Jesus there were some awesome MLK’s.
Now, I think Jesus can help people to be accountable…like in the car when you want to cut someone off you think WWJD, but I don’t think you have to have that to be good.